Inside the brewing debt limit deal

Presented by Altria: The unofficial guide to official Washington.
May 26, 2023 View in browser
 
POLITICO Playbook

By Rachael Bade, Eugene Daniels and Ryan Lizza

Presented by

Altria

With help from Eli Okun and Garrett Ross

The statue of George Washington is seen in the rotunda of the US Capitol

With mere days left before the projected June 1 X-date, negotiators appear to be homing in on a debt ceiling deal that would avert an economic catastrophe. | Stefani Reynolds /AFP via Getty Images

Play audio

Listen to to this week's episode of Playbook Deep Dive

DRIVING THE DAY

STAT OF THE DAY — As the X-date approaches, the U.S. Treasury’s cash balance has now dipped below $49.5 billion. That means “there are 24 individuals on the Bloomberg Billionaires list who have more money than the Treasury does right now,” per Bloomberg’s Kailey Leinz.

MUST-READ — “Are The Anti-Trump GOP Forces Starting to Implode?” by Jonathan Martin: “Will this go down as the week that the grand plan to deny DONALD TRUMP the nomination fell apart?” … More from JMart on today’s episode of Playbook Deep DiveListen to it on Apple Podcasts or Spotify

A quote from Jonathan Martin is pictured.

RON DeSWAMPIS — NBC’s Matt Dixon and Jonathan Allen broke a killer story late last night: “Officials who work for Gov. RON DeSANTIS’ administration — not his campaign — have been sending text messages to Florida lobbyists soliciting political contributions for DeSantis' presidential bid, a breach of traditional norms that has raised ethical and legal questions and left many here in the state capital shocked.”

Said one Florida lobbyist: “The bottom line is that the administration appears to be keeping tabs on who is giving, and are doing it using state staff. … You are in a prisoner’s dilemma. They are going to remain in power. We all understand that.”

Said another: “It is state employees leveraging their official position to ask people whose livelihood[s] depend on access to state government for money.”

A DEBT CEILING DEAL BEGINS TO TAKE SHAPE — With less than a week before a possible June 1 federal default, negotiators appear to be homing in on a debt to raise the debt ceiling and avert an economic catastrophe.

The two sides have all but finalized the spending portion of discussions, a source familiar with the talks told Playbook late last night. And as one Republican negotiator said recently, once those caps get locked in, the rest of the deal should fall into place fairly quickly.

A note of caution: As the old Washington adage goes, nothing is agreed to until everything is agreed to. Talks could blow up as conservatives and progressives balk at details that are starting to leak out. Even absent a meltdown, enough sticking points remain to drag negotiations on through the weekend.

But for once, we actually believe the White House and Republican leaders when they say there’s been real progress.

Here’s what we know this morning: 

ON SPENDING CAPS: The two sides appear to be in agreement on raising the debt ceiling for two years (through the 2024 election) and essentially capping discretionary spending over that time frame for everything except the Pentagon and veterans programs.

Where Republicans relented: GOP negotiators initially demanded that Democrats reduce spending on non-defense programs to FY 2022 levels. But they’ve now agreed to pare back those expectations and meet the White House closer to (but below) its own offer of freezing spending at FY 2023 levels.

Where Democrats relented: Because the deal will reduce non-defense discretionary spending below the FY 2023 level, Republicans can say that they secured spending cuts. But the inchoate agreement will also include accounting maneuvers to allow Democrats to shift funds from other places, meaning that the cuts are almost a wash. More details from NYT’s Jim Tankersley and Catie Edmondson

Defense spending, meanwhile, will see a small increase, matching President JOE BIDEN’s proposed 2024 budget in yet another concession from Republicans who were demanding a large influx of cash for the Pentagon. More from Roxana Tiron and Jennifer Jacobs at Bloomberg 

ON THE IRS CLAWBACKS: The still-being-ironed-out framework would also claw back $10 billion of Democrats’ $80 billion IRS funding infusion, a nod to GOP demands to rescind that money altogether. Part of that $10 billion, however, will be moved to other discretionary programs, helping Democrats avoid the steeper non-discretionary cuts demanded by the right. We’re told part of this matter is still under discussion; WaPo has more deets.

Happy Friday. Thanks for reading Playbook. Drop us a line: Rachael Bade, Eugene Daniels, Ryan Lizza.

 

A message from Altria:

The future of Tobacco Harm Reduction. More than 70% of U.S. adults 21+ surveyed support Tobacco Harm Reduction as the right path forward for tobacco regulation. And two out of three believe the FDA should focus its efforts on Tobacco Harm Reduction. See the poll results here.

 

THE STEPBACK — Progress on the spending caps and the IRS portion of talks comes days after negotiators appeared to be finalizing an agreement to recoup unspent pandemic funds. At present, it’s unclear if that Covid money will be saved altogether or merely moved around, as with the IRS funding reduction.

There are two major unresolved issues: 

1. A stalemate on work requirements. With House Democrats resisting Biden’s apparent willingness to beef up work requirements for certain social programs, the issue remains at an impasse. This is a must-have for Republicans. But with the GOP unwilling to consider something big in exchange (like closing tax loopholes for the wealthy and corporations), Democrats aren’t feeling a need to offer such a major concession — at least not yet.

2. The process of permitting reform. While both parties agree in theory that they want to include a permitting reform agreement in the deal, we’re told that the logistics of putting together such a complicated proposal by June 1 is weighing on negotiators.

The premise sounds simple enough: Democrats want to make it easier to build electricity lines and approve solar and wind energy projects; Republicans want to make it easier to drill oil — so both sides could just agree to give each other what they want.

But writing the legislation on this abbreviated timeline is difficult. One possibility: Both parties could commit to a framework and make a gentleman’s agreement to pass legislation at a later date. But some people close to talks still hold out hope legislation could be included in the debt ceiling package.

A few dynamics to keep an eye on:

1. Unhappy conservatives. As reported in Playbook PM yesterday, conservatives are already starting to revolt over the yet-to-be-finalized agreement, seething that they don’t like what they’re hearing. In a letter yesterday, members of the House Freedom Caucus urged Speaker KEVIN McCARTHY to “hold the line” and push for additional GOP priorities. Meanwhile in the Senate, MIKE LEE (R-Utah) vowed to do everything in his power to hold up passage of a deal he doesn’t like.

It didn’t get a lot of attention yesterday, but CNN’s story about MARK MEADOWS advising the Freedom Caucus as part of debt ceiling talks is worth a read. The former North Carolina Republican congressman and Trump chief of staff is a longtime McCarthy foe, and is infamous on the Hill for making ex-speakers PAUL RYAN and JOHN BOEHNER miserable. His meddling will almost surely cause problems for GOP leadership.

Watch this space closely. The more Republicans peel away from McCarthy, the more the speaker will need to rely on Democratic votes to get anything passed in the lower chamber. That could potentially mean a more watered-down bill than the agreement they’re trying to finalize now.

2. Unhappy Democrats. As we reported in Playbook yesterday, Biden’s own party continues to grumble that the White House is losing the messaging war. And House Dems are especially peeved that Biden is planning to leave Washington for the weekend. “Please tell me that’s not true,” one anonymous Dem lawmaker told our colleagues. “You’re going to see a caucus that’s so pissed if he’s stupid enough to do that.”

Meanwhile, McCarthy tweeted last night that he’s “staying in DC to fight for an agreement that’s worthy of the American people — for as long as it takes.” (Not a great side-by-side for the White House.)

Then there’s the discontent over the contents of a deal, which is prompting some surprising Democrats to warn that their votes for a deal are far from assured, according to CNN. Late last night, Rep. JARED GOLDEN (D-Maine) — the kind of moderate Democrat whose vote Biden will ultimately need — told our colleague Adam Cancryn that he remains noncommittal on backing any compromise.

Golden’s problem? The IRS rescissions, which he called “shockingly bad from a policy perspective” and would hurt the administration’s effort to crack down on tax cheats.

“They can’t count on me just because they think that’s what a Blue Dog is,” he said. “I’ve never been afraid to take tough votes, in either direction.”

3. A mischievous Trump. The former president has been cheering Republicans to embrace a default if they don’t get everything they want.

Yet that’s exactly where things stand: The tentative deal is going to look nothing like the GOP debt limit bill that passed the House a few weeks ago. Barring major changes, Republicans will have allowed Democrats to essentially continue spending at the same level for two years while raising the debt ceiling — a far cry from capping spending for a decade like they proposed.

So how will Trump react? It’s hard to tell. On the one hand, he’s never been a fiscal conservative. On the other, he loves to please the base. Should he blast the deal, swaths of Republicans will have a hard time voting for an agreement. If he blesses it, GOP leadership can keep defections to a minimum.

McCarthy appears to be aware of this wild card. Yesterday, he spoke with Trump and told reporters the former president offered one piece of advice: “Make sure you get a good agreement.”

FIRST IN PLAYBOOK — A pair of big new ad campaigns from outside organizations urge Washington to reach a debt limit deal — from different perspectives.

  • Future Forward USA Action is putting seven figures behind national TV and digital ads blasting Republicans for risking default by cowing to Trump. “With so much on the line, now is their chance to finally stand up to Trump’s chaos,” a narrator says, as “MAGA AGENDA” hovers on the screen across several images. Watch it here
  • The National Taxpayers Union supported House Republicans’ bill, but now the group is launching a roughly $300,000 ad campaign encouraging them to reach and pass a deal that also cuts spending. The TV and radio push running across “Meet the Press,” “Fox News Sunday,” WTOP, WMAL and more warns about “disastrous default.” Watch it here

TALK OF THIS TOWN — Michael Schaffer’s latest column: “Do D.C.’s Police Have an Extremism Problem?”

 

A message from Altria:

Advertisement Image

Altria is leading the way in transitioning millions of adult smokers from cigarettes to a smoke-free future.

 

BIDEN’S FRIDAY:

9:30 a.m.: The president will receive the President’s Daily Brief.

2 p.m.: The Bidens will welcome the LSU women’s basketball team for a celebration of their championship in the East Room, with VP KAMALA HARRIS speaking and second gentleman DOUG EMHOFF attending.

5 p.m.: Biden will welcome the UConn men’s basketball team for a celebration of their championship in the East Room, with Emhoff attending.

6:30 p.m.: The Bidens will leave the White House for Camp David.

THE HOUSE and THE SENATE are out.

 

DON’T MISS POLITICO’S HEALTH CARE SUMMIT: The Covid-19 pandemic helped spur innovation in health care, from the wide adoption of telemedicine, health apps and online pharmacies to mRNA vaccines. But what will the next health care innovations look like? Join POLITICO on Wednesday June 7 for our Health Care Summit to explore how tech and innovation are transforming care and the challenges ahead for access and delivery in the United States. REGISTER NOW.

 
 

PHOTO OF THE DAY

A member of the 3rd U.S. Infantry Regiment also known as The Old Guard, places flags in front of each headstone for

A member of the 3rd U.S. Infantry Regiment also known as The Old Guard, places flags in front of each headstone at Arlington National Cemetery in Arlington, Thursday, May 25, 2023. | Andrew Harnik/AP Photo

PLAYBOOK READS

2024 WATCH

JUST POSTED — “North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum Poised to Enter GOP Presidential Race,” by WSJ’s John McCormick: “Wealthy former software entrepreneur is planning a June 7 announcement in Fargo.”

MARK YOUR CALENDARS — “Fox News Sets Trump Town Hall Moderated by Sean Hannity,” by The Wrap’s Loree Seitz: “The pretaped event will air next Thursday.”

DeSANTIS, DAY ONE — The fallout from DeSantis’ roundly mocked Twitter Spaces campaign launch continued yesterday, but he plowed right through, raking in an eye-popping first-day haul and planning an aggressive schedule of campaigning and fundraising.

— The money: The campaign raised a staggering $8.2 million in its first 24 hours, NYT’s Shane Goldmacher scooped — blowing big first-day sums from past cycles, like Biden’s or BETO O’ROURKE’s, out of the water. $1 million came in during one hour alone. Donations flew in both online and from a blitz of donor calls at the Miami Four Seasons known as “Ron-o-Rama,” as Alex Isenstadt scooped. More from The Messenger’s Marc Caputo on DeSantis’ polling/strategy presentation to donors

— The media blitz: DeSantis himself started barnstorming conservative media (not the mainstream press, of course), where he finally took some pointed shots at Trump. DeSantis said the former president had moved to the left, abandoned some of his 2016 campaign positions. And he blasted Trump for erring on Covid, immigration, debt and the nomination of FBI Director CHRISTOPHER WRAY. DeSantis also cast himself as the more electable option.

But, but, but: DeSantis also made big news by saying he’d consider pardoning Trump himself, along with Jan. 6 defendants and others, on his first day in office. (One overarching promise of DeSantis’ media hits, CNN’s Steve Contorno notes: that he’ll expand the powers of the presidency in unprecedented ways.)

The tour: DeSantis announced that he’ll hit the trail next week with four days of campaigning across Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina, with a kickoff of sorts in Iowa on Tuesday. And it’s not just the public events: Puck’s Teddy Schleifer scooped the intense schedule of DeSantis fundraising travel through June, which will take the governor through Texas, California, Jersey, Vegas, Florida and more.

WARNING SIGNS FOR BIDEN — The president musters just 60% of the Democratic primary vote in the latest CNN poll, a weak showing for an incumbent who isn’t facing any top-tier opponents. ROBERT F. KENNEDY JR. pulls 20% (though you can expect that to drop as awareness of his anti-vaxxer activism catches up with last-name recognition), and MARIANNE WILLIAMSON is at 8%. More concerningly for Biden: 16% of Dem-aligned white, non-college-educated voters say they definitely would not support him in the general.

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW — Williamson sat down with our colleagues Jackie Padilla, Meiying Wu and Chris Farmer to talk about her latest presidential bid, making the case for her candidacy and explaining what’s different from her 2020 run. Watch the interview on The POLITICO Show on Snapchat

A thumbnail previews an episode of The POLITICO Show on Snapchat with Marianne Williamson.

MORE POLITICS

SOMEBODY BUY STEVE DAINES A DRINK — The Republican establishment is breathing easier today after DOUG MASTRIANO made the surprise announcement last night that he won’t run for U.S. Senate in Pennsylvania. The far-right state senator became a MAGA hero in his losing gubernatorial run last year. Now, former hedge funder DAVID McCORMICK could have an easier path if he jumps into the race, though it’s possible another more Trumpist contender could emerge, Holly Otterbein reports. State Treasurer STACY GARRITY is not ruling out a run, and the field is now “wide open,” AP’s Marc Levy writes.

But even without Mastriano, Republicans may still have trouble taking down Democratic Sen. BOB CASEY, Holly writes: “[B]ehind the scenes, GOP elected officials, strategists and donors are still not bullish about their chances.”

The Mastriano news is the latest in a string of successes for the NRSC as it tries to recruit what it sees as more electable Senate nominees than the party had last year. But the GOP will have to keep searching in Arizona, as KARRIN TAYLOR ROBSON announced that she won’t run. The wealthy establishment favorite narrowly lost to KARI LAKE in the 2022 gubernatorial primary.

 

A message from Altria:

Advertisement Image

Altria is leading the way in transitioning millions of adult smokers from cigarettes to a smoke-free future.

 

TRUMP CARDS

DOCU-DRAMA — Just a day before the FBI came to Mar-a-Lago last June to get classified materials, two Trump employees moved boxes of documents around, WaPo’s Devlin Barrett, Josh Dawsey, Spencer Hsu and Perry Stein scooped. Now federal investigators are viewing that action as potentially problematic or even as evidence of criminal obstruction as they probe Trump’s handling of classified docs. The investigation has also determined that Trump sometimes showed classified materials to visitors. All in all, the findings “suggest a greater breadth and specificity to the instances of possible obstruction … It also broadens the timeline of possible obstruction episodes that investigators are examining.”

THE WHITE HOUSE

AGAINST HATE — “White House releases national strategy to counter antisemitism,” by WaPo’s David Nakamura

WITH THE STROKE OF A PEN — “On 3rd anniversary of George Floyd’s death, Biden stops GOP-led effort to block D.C. police reform law,” by AP’s Colleen Long

CONGRESS

WITH FRIENDS LIKE THESE — “Members of a No Labels-allied caucus erupt at No Labels,” by Daniel Lippman

MENENDEZ PROBE KEEPS SIMMERING — “Did Sen. Robert Menendez and Wife Get Car, D.C. Apartment, Other ‘Gifts’ From NJ Business?” by WNBC-TV’s Jonathan Dienst, Courtney Copenhagen and Tom Winter

FIRST IN PLAYBOOK — Some of the country’s biggest sports organizations are taking on drones. The NFL, MLB, NASCAR and NCAA are sending a letter to congressional leaders urging the passage of a bipartisan bill that would strengthen counter-drone authorities for law enforcement. “The unauthorized use of drones (whether malicious or otherwise) presents a significant and rising threat to all large gatherings of people, including major sporting events,” they warn. Read the letter here

WAR EAGLE — “Sen. Tuberville’s hold on military promotions will apply to Biden’s new Joint Chiefs nominee,” by NBC’s Frank Thorp, Mike Memoli and Christina Zhao

OUTSIDER INSIDER — “Meet the ex-food writer advising Tommy Tuberville on national security,” by WaPo’s Ben Terris: “The rise of political novices has, in turn, elevated the importance of the advisers who influence them. And when it comes to Tuberville’s one-man blockade of Pentagon appointees, the Alabama senator may never have known which norm to break without MORGAN MURPHY, whose past life included a stint at Vanity Fair, a tour in Afghanistan and multiple appearances on the home-shopping network QVC.”

HOT ON THE RIGHT — “IRS ‘whistleblower’ who claimed Hunter Biden case was mishandled won’t cooperate with Senate probe,” by The Independent’s Andrew Feinberg

ONE TO WATCH — “House GOP floats blocking FBI’s new HQ,” by Jordain Carney

BEYOND THE BELTWAY

LONE STAR EARTHQUAKE — “Texas House committee issues 20 articles of impeachment against Attorney General Ken Paxton,” by The Texas Tribune’s James Barragán, Robert Downen and Zach Despart: “The House will next decide whether to approve the articles against Paxton, which could lead to the attorney general’s removal from office pending the outcome of a trial to be conducted by the Senate.”

MEDIAWATCH

DON’T SHOOT — “Jimmy Finkelstein, Low-Key Media Tycoon, Looks Beyond The Messenger’s Rocky Start,” by Vanity Fair’s Joe Pompeo

TV TONIGHT — PBS’ “Washington Week,” guest-moderated by Lisa Desjardins: Farnoush Amiri, Peter Baker, John Bresnahan and Francesca Chambers.

SUNDAY SO FAR …

FOX “Fox News Sunday”: Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) … Rep. Jim Himes (D-Conn.) … Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers (R-Wash.) and William Ostan. Panel: Charlie Hurt, Annmarie Hordern, Michael Allen and Kevin Walling.

MSNBC “The Sunday Show”: Rep. Jim Clyburn (D-S.C.) … Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) … Asa Hutchinson … Shai Akabas.

CNN “State of the Union”: New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu.

NBC “Meet the Press”: Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) … Roy Blunt. SCOTUS clerk panel: Andrew Crespo and Jennifer Mascott. Panel: Joan Biskupic, Laura Jarrett, Dahlia Lithwick and Nina Totenberg.

CBS “Face the Nation”: Brad Smith … Austan Goolsbee.

 

GET READY FOR GLOBAL TECH DAY: Join POLITICO Live as we launch our first Global Tech Day alongside London Tech Week on Thursday, June 15. Register now for continuing updates and to be a part of this momentous and program-packed day! From the blockchain, to AI, and autonomous vehicles, technology is changing how power is exercised around the world, so who will write the rules? REGISTER HERE.

 
 
PLAYBOOKERS

Ritchie Torres became the latest Democrat to call for Dianne Feinstein’s resignation.

Oprah doesn’t want to replace Feinstein.

Garret Graves dodged a question on the debt limit with a history lesson.

Andrés Manuel López Obrador waded into American politics, urging Hispanics not to support Ron DeSantis’ presidential bid.

Phil Cox and Donald Trump both teed off at a LIV Golf tournament.

Zumi, a lost puppy, was found (and reunited) via the Capitol Police.

OUT AND ABOUT — The Hispanic Heritage Foundation and the Walt Disney Co. hosted a discussion on authentic Hispanic representation in media and elsewhere in Rayburn yesterday. SPOTTED: Rep. Tony Cárdenas (D-Calif.), Yvett Merino, Jose Antonio Tijerino, Estuardo Rodriguez, Carla Rynerson, Marco Davis, William Campos, Juana Pacheco, Jaqueline Serrano, Fred Sottnick, Katie Rosborough, Adrienne Chistolini, Nigel Sanchez, Rafael Ulloa, Jeyben Castro, Nate Beltran, Isabel Sanchez, Ahmed Elsayed, Carlos Condarco, Lewis Myers and Patricia Zaragoza.

MEDIA MOVES — WSJ deputy editors-in-chief Neal Lipschutz and Jason Anders are leaving the paper, “the latest in a string of changes since [Emma] Tucker took over the newsroom in February,” NYT’s Katie Robertson reports. … Andrew McGill is starting his own product consulting firm, The Andrew McGill Company. He most recently was editor of interactive news at POLITICO.

TRANSITION — Alex Heathcock is now government affairs manager at the Economic Innovation Group. She previously was a senior associate at Cornerstone Government Affairs.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY: Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.) … Vox’s Noel KingAndrew BeileinMike Harney … NBC’s Tom Ranzweiler John BrodtkeMatt KeelenMiriam Cash … ClearPath’s Chris TomassiMorgan JacobsAllison Davis Tuck … POLITICO’s Aurora Calderone, Brenda Cruz, Thejaswini Somegowda, Steven Stiles and Jackie Padilla Hana Veselka VizcarraDina Ellis Rochkind … former Reps. Joe Cunningham (D-S.C.) and Rich Nugent (R-Fla.) … Katie Wise Keenan Austin Reed Jonathan Dach

Did someone forward this email to you? Sign up here.

Send Playbookers tips to playbook@politico.com or text us at 202-556-3307. Playbook couldn’t happen without our editor Mike DeBonis, deputy editor Zack Stanton and producers Setota Hailemariam and Bethany Irvine.

 

A message from Altria:

Moving beyond smoking. More than 20 million adult smokers are looking to transition from cigarettes to smoke-free choices. And they are three times as likely to make that change when they have information on Tobacco Harm Reduction. 

From cigarettes to smoke-free alternatives. Altria is advancing new, smoke-free products — and seeking FDA authorization to communicate with adult smokers their ability to potentially reduce harm.

From tobacco company to tobacco harm reduction company. Altria supports Tobacco Harm Reduction as a public health strategy to lower health risks associated with smoking cigarettes. Today, we are leading the way in helping millions of adult smokers transition from cigarettes to a smoke-free future.

See how we’re moving forward.

 
 

Follow us on Twitter

Rachael Bade @rachaelmbade

Eugene Daniels @EugeneDaniels2

Ryan Lizza @RyanLizza

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to ateebhassan000.ravian@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to unsubscribe.

N.Y. Today: 10 years of Citi Bike

What you need to know for Friday.

Good morning. It's Friday. We'll look at something that a transportation advocate told me was "an idea that seemed impossible, and now New York City can't live without it."

Sasha Maslov for The New York Times

On Wednesday, we said happy birthday to the Brooklyn Bridge and celebrated how transformative it was. Citi Bike is only 10, as of tomorrow, but it, too, has changed the city in many ways.

Citi Bike, operated by the ride-share company Lyft, has tried to count those ways.

It says its initial fleet of 6,000 bicycles went out on 46,854 rides in that first week on the streets, enough to put the entire population of Palm Springs, Calif., or Charlottesville, Va., on two-wheelers.

Since then, ridership has exploded: Two weeks ago, Citi Bike customers went on 867,840 rides, a record. And the company now has just under 30,000 bikes. About 6,000 of them are e-bikes.

"It's been extremely transformative," said Sarah Kaufman, the interim director of the Rudin Center for Transportation at New York University. "It's opened up New York to a viable alternative mode of transportation. It's opened up areas of the city that were previously underserved by transit. And it was instrumental in 2020 when the pandemic hit and people were seeking socially distanced modes of travel."

It also had New Yorkers saying that cycling was cool. "When it launched, it was like lightning in a bottle," said Edward Skyler, a former deputy mayor who, as an executive vice president of Citibank, now oversees the bank's sponsorship of Citi Bike. Social media posts with celebrities — "Leonardo DiCaprio taking a ride on a Citi Bike with his new girlfriend," as Skyler described one — provided "promotion we hadn't anticipated," he told me.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

Citi Bike's hipness quotient has continued, most recently with a cameo appearance on the HBO series "Succession." Citibank is so committed to Citi Bike that Skyler said it has already extended its sponsorship arrangement through 2034. The deal that expires next year was worth $70.5 million. The terms of the new deal have not been disclosed.

'An idea that seemed impossible' that New York can't live without

Danny Harris, the executive director of Transportation Alternatives, a bicycle and pedestrian safety advocacy group, called Citi Bike "another one of those great examples of an idea that seemed impossible, and now New York City can't exist without it."

But he followed that sentence with "and yet." Citi Bike is still not in every neighborhood, he said, and the city is behind on its commitment to build protected bike lanes.

The blue bikes became familiar sights in Manhattan soon after the program began, but Citi Bike got off to a wobbly start. After nearly 18 months, The New York Times said it had been "pedaling toward oblivion since the day it began." Lyft took over in 2018 and announced a $100 million capital infusion intended to double the size of the Citi Bike service area and increase the number of bikes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

Lyft's arrival roughly coincided with rising frustration about subway and bus delays, which prompted more people to take up biking. Some who have followed the Citi Bike evolution say that along the way, the attitude on the streets changed. Janette Sadik-Khan, who was the city's transportation commissioner when Citi Bike made its debut, said it used to be that riding a bike in New York was "blood sport, like a Mad Max warrior on a city street."

Now, she told me, more than half a million people ride bicycles in the city every day, more than the number of cars on the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway and the Cross Bronx Expressway combined. The city Department of Transportation says bicycle traffic over the East River bridges reached new highs last year, with more than 24,000 bike trips a day.

Lanes to ride on

The city has worked on building up its network of bike lanes, although critics like Harris say that the new lanes did not come fast enough and that not enough of them are protected, meaning they have barriers to keep bicycles and automobiles apart.

In 2013, the city had about 830 miles of bicycle lanes, with roughly 500 miles of protected lanes, the vast majority in parks and open spaces: Only 30 miles of protected lanes were on streets. Now the city has 1,500 miles of bicycle lanes, with more than 200 miles of protected lanes on streets.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

Harris says the city fell short last year, putting in fewer protected miles of protected lanes than the 30 called for in the NYC Streets Plan, a transportation master plan mandated by the City Council in 2019. A spokesman for the Department of Transportation said the city installed 26.3 miles last year, "quite close to the 30."

Under the streets plan, 50 miles of protected lanes are supposed to be installed this year. Harris said that only four miles have been created so far; the group's website says 22 miles are under construction. The department spokesman said "there is going to be a record production of protected bike lanes" in 2023, adding that "the goal is to make it to 50."

'Reflects the population of New York City a lot more than it used to'

Like Citi Bikes themselves, Citi Bike docking stations became part of the landscape. But the company was criticized for seeming to cater to wealthier neighborhoods. It did not expand to the Bronx until 2019.

"It has improved, but it is not improved to the level we think it should," Olivia Leirer, the co-executive director of New York Communities for Change, which issued a sharply critical report on Citi Bike's neighborhood coverage in 2019, told me.

Citi Bike now has more than 1,800 bike stands around the city, not quite six times the number it started with in 2013. Caroline Samponaro, Lyft's vice president of transit, bike and scooter policy, said the company has "radically shifted the demographics." Citi Bike, she said, "reflects the population of New York City a lot more than it used to."

The company says that 51 percent of its riders now come from communities of color, that 64 percent of its station network is outside Manhattan and that Citi Bikes will be available in 70 percent of city-run public housing by the end of the year.

Citi Bike sees more of an electric future ahead. It is looking into "in-station charging" — bicycle docks that can charge the batteries on its e-bikes.

These days, Citi Bike sends vans from one docking station to another with workers who check the batteries and the chains, pedals and tires. They take out batteries that are running low and put in fully charged ones. Samponaro said that electrifying 20 to 30 percent of the docking stations would reduce battery swaps by nearly 90 percent.

WEATHER

Enjoy a sunny day with a high near 72. At night, expect mostly clear skies and a low around 58 with light wind.

ALTERNATE-SIDE PARKING

Suspended today and tomorrow (Shavuot) and Monday (Memorial Day).

The latest Metro news

Pool photo by Curtis Means
  • Stephen Bannon trial: The longtime adviser to Donald Trump will go on trial next May on money laundering and conspiracy charges for his role in an organization that raised millions with a promise to make the southern border wall a reality.
  • Shoved against a train: Emine Yilmaz Ozsoy, an artist and illustrator, was partially paralyzed after being shoved against a speeding subway train.
  • A papaya king dies: Nicholas Gray's unlikely pairing of hot dogs and papaya juice became a New York institution. He was 86.
  • What we're watching: Betsy Gotbaum, executive director of Citizens Union, joins "The New York Times Close Up With Sam Roberts." And Ed Shanahan, who has been covering breaking news on the Metro desk, discusses his story on Jay Salpeter, who cracked a high-profile case — which turned out to be a blessing and a curse. The show airs on Friday at 5 p.m., Saturday at 5 p.m., and Sunday at 5 p.m. [CUNY TV]

Subscribe Today

We hope you've enjoyed this newsletter, which is made possible through subscriber support. Subscribe to The New York Times with this special offer.

METROPOLITAN DIARY

Hey, babe

Dear Diary:

I was at a bagel shop on Lorimer Street on a very busy Sunday morning. The crowd of people waiting for their orders was packed to the walls. I and another young man had been waiting up against the counter for a while.

"What did you order again, babe?" the woman running sandwiches called out in our direction.

The other guy began to answer.

"No," she corrected him while indicating that she had meant me, "the other babe."

"Lotta babes in here," he said in a thick Brooklyn accent. We both laughed.

Several minutes later, he was the lucky one: His order was ready.

"Later, babe," I said casually as he walked past me. He was facing the other way, but I could still hear him laugh.

"Later, babe!" he replied.

— Justin Hanagan

Glad we could get together here. See you on Monday — J.B.

Jaevon Williams, Melissa Guerrero, Jeffrey Furticella, Rick Martinez, and Olivia Parker contributed to New York Today. You can reach the team at nytoday@nytimes.com.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for New York Today from The New York Times.

To stop receiving New York Today, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebooktwitter

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018